Unlocking Success: Key Traits and Strategies of Transactional Leadership

LEADERSHIP-STYLES

Discover the key traits of transactional leadership and learn simple strategies to boost your success. Click here to start your journey!

What motivates your team to perform their best—rewards, recognition, or a clear chain of command?

If structure and discipline drive results, transactional leadership might be the secret ingredient your organisation needs.

But is it the right fit for every team or workplace? Let’s find out.

In this article, we’ll discuss the pros and cons of transactional leadership. We will also examine how to decide if it’s the right style for your organisation.

---

☰ KEY TAKEAWAYS

Definition: Transactional leadership is a structured, goal-oriented style focusing on rewards and punishments to motivate team members.

Core Characteristics: Includes a directive approach, emphasis on hierarchy, and maintaining the status quo over fostering innovation.

Benefits: Effective in environments requiring strict rules, stability, and short-term goal achievement.

Drawbacks: Lacks emphasis on employee fulfilment, collaboration, and long-term innovation, making it less suitable for modern, dynamic workplaces.

Relevance Today: Declining in popularity due to a shift towards employee well-being and collaborative leadership models.

What is transactional leadership?

In 1947, Max Weber first introduced the transactional leadership style, and Bernard Bass followed suit in 1981 [1].

As its name implies, transactional leadership is a “transactional” process involving two people. These are the leader and the follower. They must interact to achieve certain goals.

Transactional leadership appeals to the self-interest of each team member. It motivates them to execute well in exchange for perks or rewards.

But how do you know if it’s right for your team?

Transactional leadership is a style of leadership that focuses on order, structure, and goal-oriented planning.

• A transactional leader will directly instruct their team on what to do.
• This leadership style prioritises maintaining the status quo rather than challenging it.

According to this framework, leaders keep strict hierarchical authority over their followers.

• Followers are expected to respect their leaders.
• They must carry out commands without questioning or challenging the leader’s authority.

Characteristics of transactional leadership

In organisations where structure is essential, transactional leadership excels. Yet, transactional leadership is inappropriate for organisations that encourage initiative.

Here are some of the characteristics of transactional leadership:

• Extrinsic motivation: transactional leaders motivate employees externally to achieve organisational goals. They reward employees for meeting goals and behaving well. The manager will punish an employee who doesn’t behave or meet expectations.
• Discourage innovation: transactional leadership hinders innovation. Employees must follow rules and procedures. They don’t encourage innovative ideas to improve the process.
• Directive: transactional leadership excludes employees from decision-making. They believe that the company’s management should make all decisions. All employees should follow those decisions and procedures.
• Interest in a hierarchy: transactional leaders prioritise organisational hierarchy. They treat employees based on their hierarchy. They prioritise creating a business structure.
• Emphasis on self-achievement: transactional leaders encourage employees to reach personal goals. They don’t encourage teamwork or success. If an employee meets a goal, the leader will reward them; if not, they’ll be punished.

Pros and cons of transactional leadership

Much of transactional leadership’s benefits go to the employer, not the employee.

• Transactional leadership benefits companies more than individuals or teams.
• This leadership style prioritises short-term gains and the present over building happy, healthy, reliable, and intrinsically inspired teams.

In the last decade, transactional leadership has declined.

• With more millennials in the workforce, more industries are focusing on work-life balance.
• Employee fulfilment is becoming important.

These aren’t priorities under transactional leadership.

FAQs

Q1: What are the main characteristics of transactional leadership?

The main traits include external motivation through rewards and punishments. A directive style does not allow employee feedback. There is a focus on hierarchy and rules. The environment lacks innovation. Individual goals are put ahead of teamwork.

Q2: What are some potential benefits of transactional leadership?

Potential benefits include maintaining structure and order, which can be good for organisations where stability is important. It also focuses on short-term goals and task completion.

Q3: What are some drawbacks of transactional leadership?

Drawbacks include a lack of employee fulfilment. Innovation tends to decrease. There is a reliance on hierarchy over collaboration. There is also a tendency to focus on short-term gains over long-term team or company success.

Q4: When is transactional leadership most effective?

Transactional leadership works best for organisations that need strict adherence to rules and procedures. This occurs in environments where innovation is not a high priority, like in some manufacturing settings.

Q5: Is transactional leadership still widely used today?

Transactional leadership has declined in popularity in recent decades as more companies focus on employee well-being, work-life balance, and collaboration. It’s less common today than it once was.

Conclusion

Transactional leadership is a style of leadership that focuses on order, structure, and goal-oriented planning.

A transactional leader prioritises maintaining the status quo rather than challenging it. In organisations where structure is essential, transactional leadership excels, but it’s inappropriate for organisations that encourage initiative.

In the last decade, transactional leadership has declined. With more millennials in the workforce, more industries are focusing on work-life balance and employee fulfilment.

Transactional leadership prioritises short-term gains and the present over building happy, healthy, reliable, and intrinsically inspired teams.

Reference:

[1] https://www.managementstudyguide.com/transactional-leadership.htm

---

Thanks for reading…

If you enjoyed reading my story, please highlight any parts you think other readers would find interesting.

A couple of claps 👏 wouldn’t go amiss, either.

Don’t forget to leave your comments about what you thought of this story.

Consider following me here on Medium and subscribing to my stories.