Giving effective employee feedback

Giving employees feedback is an essential aspect of managing a team. It allows leaders to provide constructive criticism and praise to help employees develop and grow in their roles. But giving effective feedback can be challenging, and many managers struggle to do it well. This blog post will provide you with the ultimate guide to giving effective employee feedback. We cover feedback’s significance and diverse types and offer guidelines for giving effective feedback.

Table of contents:

Why is employee feedback important?

Feedback is really important in all areas of life, but particularly at work. Feedback can improve job performance, motivation, and organisational success. Feedback helps employees improve and develop in their job roles.

For example, a manager may give constructive criticism to an employee who struggles with meeting deadlines. The feedback could include specific areas for improvement, such as time management or prioritisation skills, and offer resources or support to help the employee improve.

On the other hand, the manager could also offer praise and recognition for an employee who consistently exceeds expectations, highlighting their specific contributions and impact on the team or company. This type of feedback can boost morale and motivation, leading to increased job satisfaction and productivity.
Without feedback, employees may continue to make the same mistakes or miss opportunities for growth. Additionally, feedback helps build trust and transparency between managers and employees, fostering a positive work environment.

Types of employee feedback

There are two primary types of feedback: positive and constructive. Positive feedback reinforces good behaviour, while constructive feedback addresses areas for improvement. Both types of feedback are important and should be used regularly to help employees grow and develop.

Positive Feedback

Positive feedback is essential to creating a positive work environment. It reinforces good behaviour, encourages employees to continue doing good work, and boosts morale. Positive feedback can be given in person, via email, or even in an announcement to the whole company.

For example, a manager might give positive feedback to an employee who went above and beyond in completing a project. The manager could send an email recognising the employee’s hard work and thanking them for their dedication to the company. This type of positive reinforcement can motivate employees to continue performing at a high level and increase their job satisfaction.

Constructive Feedback

Constructive feedback is critical to helping employees improve their performance. It addresses areas for improvement and provides specific examples of how employees can improve. Constructive feedback should be given in a private setting and framed in a way that is not accusatory or negative.

For instance, during a performance review, a supervisor might provide constructive feedback to an employee who has been struggling with meeting deadlines. The supervisor could give specific examples of missed deadlines and suggest ways for the employee to better manage their time and prioritise tasks. This type of feedback can help employees grow professionally and ultimately contribute more effectively to the company’s goals.

Best practises for giving employee feedback

After discussing the value of feedback and the various types of feedback, let’s look at some best practises for providing feedback to employees.

Be specific

Feedback should be specific, clear, and actionable. Instead of just giving a general “great job,” you could personalise your feedback by saying, “I really appreciated the level of detail you put into the project plan. It was instrumental in keeping us on track and finishing the project within our deadline.” This specific and detailed feedback will help the employee understand exactly what they did well and encourage them to continue performing at a high level.

Be timely

Give feedback as close to the event as possible. This ensures that the feedback is relevant and accurate. Delayed feedback can lead to confusion or frustration and may not be as effective. 

For example, if you noticed a team member effectively handling a difficult customer interaction, provide positive feedback soon after the interaction occurred. This will show that you value their communication and problem-solving skills and encourage them to continue demonstrating those skills in future interactions.

Focus on behaviour

Feedback should focus on behaviour, not the person. Address specific actions or outcomes, rather than generalising about an employee’s character or abilities.

For instance, instead of saying, “You’re always so disorganised,” say, “I noticed that you missed the deadline for submitting the report yesterday. Let’s discuss how we can work together to ensure that it doesn’t happen again.” This approach helps the employee understand what they need to improve on without feeling personally attacked.

Offer solutions

When providing constructive feedback, offer solutions or suggestions for improvement. This helps employees understand how they can improve and take action to do so. 

For example, instead of simply pointing out mistakes in a project, offer specific steps for improvement and provide resources or support to help the employee achieve success. This approach empowers the employee to take ownership of their development and encourages a culture of continuous improvement.

Use the “Sandwich” method

The “sandwich” method involves sandwiching constructive feedback between two pieces of positive feedback. This helps balance the feedback and ensures that employees feel valued and appreciated, even when receiving constructive criticism.

For instance, if an employee struggled with meeting a deadline, the sandwich method could involve starting with positive feedback on their hard work on the project, addressing the missed deadline and providing specific solutions to improve time management skills, and ending with positive feedback on their overall performance and potential for growth. This approach can help maintain a positive relationship between the employee and manager while still providing valuable feedback.


Here are five frequently asked questions related to giving effective employee feedback:

Q1: How do I give feedback to employees who are defensive?

Giving feedback to defensive employees can be a real toughie, but it’s crucial to handle the situation with kindness and empathy. First, try to understand why the employee is being defensive. Are they feeling attacked or criticised? Try to see things from their point of view and then give feedback that addresses the problem instead of making it personal. When you give feedback to your employees, try to use language that is constructive and collaborative. Instead of saying “You’re not meeting your targets,” try saying “Let’s work together to improve our results.” Also, listen actively and acknowledge your employee’s feelings. When giving feedback, remember to be respectful and empathetic, and treat it as a conversation for growth and development. This can help defuse the defensiveness and lead to a more productive conversation.

Q2: Should I give feedback in public or private?

Ideally, feedback should be given in private to avoid embarrassing the employee or making them feel defensive in front of others. Sometimes, giving feedback in public is necessary, especially when the behaviour is affecting the whole team. When giving feedback, focus on the behaviour, not the person. Be respectful and professional in your tone.

Q3: How often should I give feedback to employees?

Feedback should be given regularly, not just during performance reviews or when something goes wrong. It’s best to give feedback regularly as you interact with your team members. This helps fix problems quickly and gives employees a chance to make improvements.

Q4: How do I give feedback that is specific and actionable?

When giving feedback, be specific about the behavior or issue you want to address. Use examples and describe the impact of the behaviour on the team or organisation. Make sure to provide practical suggestions for how your employee can improve, and work together with them to create an action plan to tackle the problem. Remember, listen to your employee’s perspective and find a solution that benefits both of you to help them grow and develop.

Q5: What should I do if the employee doesn’t take my feedback well?

Even with the best feedback delivery, employees may still not take it well at times. If this happens, try to understand their perspective and address their concerns. Take a break if needed and resume the conversation later. Giving feedback is a continuous process, and it may take time for the employee to process and act on it.


In conclusion, giving effective employee feedback is a critical skill for any manager or leader. Effective feedback can significantly impact employee performance and motivation, ultimately contributing to the overall success of the organization. However, giving feedback can be challenging and requires a thoughtful and empathetic approach. Improve your feedback-giving skills and help your team members reach their full potential by implementing the tips and strategies provided in this article. Remember to give feedback regularly, focus on the behavior rather than the person, and provide specific and actionable suggestions for improvement. Don’t underestimate the power of effective feedback in driving employee performance and engagement. With practice and dedication, you can become a feedback master and help your team achieve great things. With practise and patience, you can become a feedback pro and help your team thrive.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Website Powered by

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: